The Best Car Insurance For Millennials

Millennials, also known as Generation Y, are the demographic between Generation X and Generation Z. They are typically born between 1981 and 1996 and are the children of baby boomers and early Generation Xers. Currently, most Millennials are aged between 25 and 40. They are actively working, raising families, and heavily reliant on driving for transportation. Many Millennials are seeking optimal car insurance options, whether for enhanced coverage or lower premiums. In this article, we explore the top car insurance choices for Millennials.
Clearcover Insurance
Clearcover Insurance is a forward-thinking company leveraging technology to provide cost-effective automotive coverage for Millennials. By eliminating traditional marketing methods and human intermediaries, they utilize artificial intelligence to offer highly affordable insurance rates.
Their car insurance application process is streamlined through an online app, providing almost instant qualification feedback. Additionally, Clearcover facilitates claim filing directly within the app, allowing users to describe incidents and upload visual evidence, such as photos or videos, from their mobile devices. Remarkably, insurance adjusters are not required for claims processing with Clearcover.
California Casualty
Millennials working in public service roles can benefit from California Casualty for their car insurance needs. Despite being headquartered in Colorado Springs, Colorado, the company extends special discounts to first responders and those involved in civic activities.
Eligible professions include firefighters, paramedics, nurses, police officers, educators, and select college staff. Discounts offered by California Casualty can be substantial, ranging from 10% to 25%, contingent upon your driving history. If you’re a Millennial serving on the frontlines, exploring California Casualty for your car insurance is highly recommended.
Say Insurance
The insurance industry relies heavily on your “insurance score” to determine your rate. This score is a comprehensive calculation that considers various factors such as your driving history, claims record, and credit score. Unfortunately, many people are unaware of their insurance score and how it’s determined.
With insurance companies keeping this information under wraps, Millennials often find themselves puzzled by high premiums, even with a clean driving record. Say Insurance aims to shed light on this by disclosing your insurance score when you apply for coverage. Additionally, they offer tips on how you can enhance your score. A higher score typically translates to lower premiums.
Metromile
Metromile stands out with its “pay per mile car insurance” model, making it an excellent choice for Millennials who work remotely, have short commutes, or prefer alternative modes of transportation like walking or biking. This innovative insurance plan charges a base rate starting at $29 per month, along with a few cents for every mile driven.
Many Metromile users find themselves paying $50 or less monthly. Additionally, the company offers pet injury coverage along with collision and comprehensive coverage on all policies. If you’ve transitioned to a work-from-home setup and seldom use your car, Metromile could be a cost-effective option. Why pay full insurance premiums for a vehicle that rarely leaves the parking spot?
Amica Mutual Insurance

Amica Mutual Insurance stands out for its remarkable cost savings and exceptional customer service, making it a top choice for Millennials. Not only does Amica offer competitive rates, but it also provides annual dividend payments to its policyholders.
As a mutual company, Amica distributes a portion of its profits back to its customers in the form of dividend payments. These dividends typically range from 5% to 20% of the premiums paid annually. If you appreciate receiving cashback rewards from your financial products, consider Amica Mutual Insurance for your car insurance needs.
State Auto Insurance
For extensive coverage that goes beyond just your vehicle, consider State Auto Insurance. With around 70% of Millennials owning pets and nearly all owning smartphones, State Auto offers protection for both, all included in their “AutoXtended” policy at no additional charge.
This comprehensive policy not only safeguards your family pet and phones in case of an accident but also covers various other expenses such as emergency travel, bail bonds, locksmith or key replacement, emergency ambulance transportation, and disability coverage. With State Auto Insurance, you can enjoy peace of mind knowing that you and your assets are well protected.
Verti Insurance
While insurance companies utilizing artificial intelligence may offer cost savings, they often lack a personal touch. During challenging situations like a car accident, having the support of a compassionate human can be invaluable.
Verti Insurance stands out by providing car insurance in Pennsylvania with not only affordable premiums but also personalized service through their dedicated Personal Advisor service. This service ensures that a real human is available via phone, text, or email at any time, day or night. Additionally, Verti offers a user-friendly app for quick access to assistance during emergencies. However, it’s their commitment to personalized service that truly sets them apart.
Safeco Insurance
Safeco, owned by Liberty Mutual, stands out as a highly regarded insurance provider offering tailored options for Millennials. Their “RightTrack” policy allows safe drivers to save up to 30% by using a smartphone app to track driving behaviors like acceleration, braking, and mileage. Moreover, pet owners can easily add pet coverage to most Safeco policies. For part-time Uber and Lyft drivers, Safeco offers affordable “RideSharing” coverage to ensure protection while using their vehicles for income. Given the growing popularity of the gig economy among Millennials, Safeco Insurance could be worth exploring.
Root Insurance
Root Insurance sets itself apart with its cutting-edge mobile application, packed with a myriad of features. From tracking driving habits to providing instant quotes and facilitating direct claim filing and roadside assistance calls, Root Insurance’s app offers comprehensive functionality for users.
Given its focus on insuring only safe drivers, Root Insurance often offers notably low rates to eligible individuals. According to the company, many customers experience savings exceeding 50% compared to their previous insurance premiums, equating to an average annual saving of $1,187—an attractive prospect for any Millennial seeking to cut costs. However, it’s crucial to maintain a pristine driving record to qualify for these substantial discounts.
Good2Go Insurance

Good2Go Insurance targets young drivers and individuals with less-than-ideal driving histories by offering affordable coverage options. Primarily focusing on state-minimum insurance plans with low premiums and deductibles, Good2Go further incentivizes safe driving behavior through discounts for users of the “LifeSaver” distracted-driving app.
Although it may not suit every driver, Good2Go can be particularly beneficial for younger Millennials with limited driving experience or a history of accidents. Securing affordable car insurance can be challenging after experiencing multiple claims, making Good2Go a potentially valuable solution for those in need of budget-friendly coverage.
Elephant Insurance
Elephant stands out as an excellent choice for budget-conscious young drivers seeking affordable car insurance options. With discounts of up to 40% available for meeting specific criteria, such as opting for paperless transactions, maintaining a good payment history, and demonstrating safe driving habits, Elephant offers substantial savings opportunities.
For newly licensed drivers or those with limited driving experience, Elephant Insurance provides significant cost savings beyond just driving behavior or insurance scores. Simple actions like choosing electronic statements over mailed ones or consistently making timely payments can lead to substantial discounts, making Elephant a compelling option for young drivers looking to save money on their insurance premiums.
Empower Insurance
Based in Texas and founded in 2003 by a team of Generation Z entrepreneurs, Empower Insurance specializes in catering to Millennials, particularly those with less-than-ideal credit histories. Despite its youthful leadership, Empower has honed its focus on providing car insurance solutions tailored to the needs of this demographic.
One of Empower’s key features is its willingness to extend coverage to individuals with bad credit, making it an appealing option for those who may face difficulties obtaining affordable insurance elsewhere. By disregarding credit scores in their premium calculations, Empower ensures accessibility to a broader range of customers. While this approach carries some level of risk, it enables Empower to serve individuals who might otherwise struggle to find suitable and affordable car insurance options.
Lemonade Insurance
Lemonade Insurance, a relatively new player in the industry, has garnered attention by operating exclusively online, bypassing the need for physical offices. While they currently offer a range of insurance products including home, life, renters, and pet insurance, auto insurance is not yet part of their offerings.
However, Lemonade has announced plans to introduce car insurance in the near future. Interested customers can sign up for email notifications to stay informed about the launch. If Lemonade maintains its reputation for competitive pricing, online accessibility, and efficient claims processing with its auto insurance, it is likely to find favor among Millennials seeking comprehensive coverage options.